On this dayFeb 19, 1923
U.S. Supreme Court Rules Indian Immigrants Ineligible for Citizenship
On February 19, 1923, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a ruling legally barring all Indians from becoming U.S. citizens and revoking citizenship from many who had attained it. Bhagat Singh Thind, an Indian Sikh man born in Punjab, migrated to the U.S. in 1913. After enlisting in the U.S. Army, Mr. Thind applied and obtained approval for citizenship in 1920. Though Mr. Thind entered the country prior to the Immigration Restriction Act of 1917, which barred all immigration to the U.S. from Asia, the Bureau of Naturalization appealed the grant of his citizenship request and the case went to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Mr. Thind had filed for citizenship under the Naturalization Act of 1906, which said that citizenship is available for “free whites.” Mr. Thind argued to the Supreme Court that, under anthropological classifications of the time, Indians of the “high caste” from his native region of Punjab were “Aryan,” and thus white for purposes of American law. The Court conceded that, ethnologically, Indians were “Aryan” and thus Caucasian; however, the court ruled that the words “white people” in American statutory language had to be taken at their common meaning, and that “the average man knows perfectly well that there are unmistakable and profound differences.” The Court reasoned that Indians are not able to assimilate the way more typical “white” immigrants can, and held that a scientific study cannot determine citizenship. As a result, they held that Mr. Thind was not white and was legally barred from becoming a U.S. citizen.
The decision had a significant impact. Many Indians who had previously obtained U.S. citizenship in the U.S. now had their citizenship revoked, and lost many rights and privileges as a result. In California, the 1913 Alien Land Act barred non-citizens from owning land, and Indian Americans in the state who lost their citizenship also lost their land. Following the Thind decision, America’s Indian immigrant population dropped by half.